Reviews

Star Rating:

***** Petrinos Pizzeria In Zeeland is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars, based on 42 reviews!

  • *****

    Great pizzeria! You walk in the door and employees yell hi immediately. They seem genuinely happy you are there and it makes you want to go there again. Value for the money is average to good and the food is awesome! So many value packages and pizzas to choose from. Great pizza place!

  • *****

    Really love there delicious food and you definitely get what you pay for. Great staff...great service....hats off to you guys for being so awesome.

  • *****

    Their 24incher was awesome!! That was enough to feed an army!

  • *****

    Never disappoints! You get your money's worth and it tastes amazing!

  • *****

    Just had take out with my family. The chicken club was excellent!

  • *****

    As always it's absolutely wonderful ordering from Patrinos. Though sometimes the staff can be creepy ..... Just kidding. But for real they always know what I need and go above and beyond. I don't eat anywhere else really while I'm at work.

  • *****

    Michigans best pizza,hands down. Excellent service

  • *****

    A family favorite! I have never been disappointed. Wonderful service and AMAZING pizza. Love their sauce .. Thanks Petrino's!

  • *****

    My favorite in Zeeland! Delicious pizza, great service!

  • *****

    My fellow bus driver and I stop here all the time between runs for lunch. Staff has always been friendly and smiling. Hard working family. Pizza had always been excellent. Their four cheese pizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza are out if this world good.

  • *****

    Number one in zeeland!!!! Congratuletion very Hood pizzeria

  • *****

    Best pizza around. Forget that Chicago style stuff, stick with petrino's

  • *****

    Our family has been coming here for over 6 years and have always been satisfied. I love the real authentic taste of the sauce especially and the crust. Always have pretty good deals and friendly staff although I will admit I too have been over charged or told the wrong prices.

  • *****

    Ordered a 16" 1 topping for lunch with feta on it. The reviews I read are absolutely true. I really enjoy Vitale's pizza, but this place sure gives them a run for their money.

    The crust is just thin enough to absorb the grease form the mozzarella and adding the feta cheese on was a great idea. It's a premium topping and cost an extra $2, but was totally worth it.

    I would like absolutely love to give a 5 star rating, but the $3 delivery charge for going 1/4 of a mile is a little much. My job doesn't allow for me to leave the premiss, so I'm forced to get delivery. Other than that, there nothing stopping me from ordering from here again. In reality I would be happy giving them a 4.5 star rating, but Yelp doesn't allow for half stars.

  • *****

    I moved to Zeeland from the NY / NJ metro area in November 2014. I say that to say that since I moved here I've been frantically searching for a good slice of pizza in West Michigan. I for the most part have been thoroughly let down by the pizza out here. Fortunately, Petrino's however has proven to be a breath of fresh air!

    I've ordered delivery a few times from them over the past 6 months. They seem to be the only place in the area that I found that can make a thin crust pizza. They also have a greasier slice than your average West Michigan pizza. As a long time cook myself, this leads me to believe they are using whole milk mozzarella whereas some of the other establishments are using part skim mozzarella. While I love the more greasy pizza, the downfall of Petrino's is that since it's a thinner crust frequently the pizza crust is flimsy and flops over when you pick up a slice. It's not uncommon for me to have to use a fork and knife to eat the slices. One way around this, is to ask for the pizza well down with a crisp crust. Also I found that they use a lot of cheese on their pizza (especially if you order a plain pie) Despite these criticisms, I reluctantly say that this is the most authentic New York pizza in the Holland-Zeeland area.

    Also, I feel compelled to mention this. The strombolis here are amazing! Their strombolis are pretty simple, as they should be. They have just ham, pepperoni, and mozzarella in them and are brushed with oil prior to cooking which gives them a nice golden and crispy outside. I recommend getting the large. It's about $13 though you will be amazed as to the size of the 'boli. It's pretty close to 2 feet long!!! It's easily 2 large meals. Buon Appetito!

  • *****

    Plenty of food for two people (pizza by the slice) and drink and Italian bites for $10 even!

  • *****

    great food at a great price one of my family's favorite

  • *****

    There specialty pizzas are great & I encourage anyone to try there picante special along with any of there herb bread orders you can't go wrong, good service & the owner who is Italian from the ol country brings you his best everytime!

  • *****

    Sells very large pizza by the slice for lunch, great quick lunch stop.

  • *****

    Some of the best pizza I've had in west Michigan. Decent prices as well

  • *****

    Fabulous service, they're so friendly and accommodating. They went over and above when we went in for our son's birthday, they brought out good as soon as we sat down and the owner came out to say 'happy birthday' and gave him a free cannoli. So great!!!

  • *****

    Local favorite. Huge slices.

  • *****

    Our family loves it here

  • *****

    Ordered a 16" 1 topping for lunch with feta on it. The reviews I read are absolutely true. I really enjoy Vitale's pizza, but this place sure gives them a run for their money.

    The crust is just thin enough to absorb the grease form the mozzarella and adding the feta cheese on was a great idea. It's a premium topping and cost an extra $2, but was totally worth it.

    I would like absolutely love to give a 6 star rating, but the $3 delivery charge for going 1/4 of a mile is a little much. My job doesn't allow for me to leave the premiss, so I'm forced to get delivery. Other than that, there nothing stopping me from ordering from here again. In reality I would be happy giving them a 4.5 star rating, but Yelp doesn't allow for half stars.

  • *****

    Pizza is delicious. Best sauce I've ever had. Could do without the bible on the pedestal while waiting in line though. According to the gospel, you shouldn't even be eating pizza.

  • *****

    Stopped in and got a 24" Deluxe, Very nice and great service. The pizza was huge and Great

  • *****

    Best food ever!! The bread bites are a must have

  • *****

    Pretty good pizza. We tried both regular pizza and the party style and both had good flavor. Lots of salty Parmesan taste.
    The breadsticks are a huge hit with the kids.
    Employees are friendly if not too rushed.

  • *****

    Great crust! With double cheese no one beats this pizza. The sauce is great. Would like a little friendlier service.

  • *****

    Very good

  • *****

    Great food..Great People...

  • *****

    Really great pizza. But terrible service, I've been incorrectly given my total several times and had to correct them from over charging me when picking up my order.

  • *****

    Best pizza I've ever had

  • *****

    Nice people and great food. Order from there weekly. Convenient for Gentex

  • *****

    Great pizza. We had the pesto chicken. Yum!

  • *****

    + Pizza is old-school when it comes to sizes.
    + I don't know what it's called but I really like the chicken ranch pizza with broccoli and tomatoes!

    My first impression of this place was that they could be a little friendlier (I was taken off guard on my first visit). For the most part, they are super nice though, especially the gals in the afternoon! :)

  • *****

    My husband and I get pizza by the slice almost every Tuesday. We love it. The service is fantastic and I would highly recommend thier chicago style.

  • *****

    OH MY this is the best pizza ever. I can not say enough good things about this pizza store. Who ever did the review that was not a 5 star must have been to some other pizza store in Zeeland. I eat pizza … more OH MY this is the best pizza ever. I can not say enough good things about this pizza store. Who ever did the review that was not a 5 star must have been to some other pizza store in Zeeland. I eat pizza at leat once a week and have had it from a lot of good pizza storys but this is one of the best. MUST TRY!!!!!!! Can not tell enough people how great it is.

  • *****

    Amazing!
    Best pizza I've ever had! The service is excellent!

  • *****

    + Pizza is old-school when it comes to sizes!
    + I tried their pizza which wasn't bad but you gotta' try their meatball sub...wow!

  • *****

    I've been here a few times, to me, they're the best pizza place in Zeeland, not that it's a pizza mecca or anything.  I've had their pizza slices for lunch as well as their stromboli.  The pizza, well, it's about as good as you can expect for lunch time slices, they're reasonably fresh, and flavorful, usually with a pretty good variety to choose from.  The stromboli, is pretty much everything I'm looking for, quality cheese, which reheats properly, with a golden brown crust, coated in garlic butter and Parmesan.   Plus that sauce that comes on the side has excellent flavor.  My only complaint is that they don't have online ordering, but really, I can't expect that from a small pizza place.

  • *****

    I moved to Zeeland from the NY / NJ metro area in November 2014.  I say that to say that since I moved here I've been frantically searching for a good slice of pizza in West Michigan.  I for the most part have been thoroughly let down by the pizza out here.  Fortunately, Petrino's however has proven to be a breath of fresh air!

    I've ordered delivery a few times from them over the past 6 months.  They seem to be the only place in the area that I found that can make a thin crust pizza.  They also have a greasier slice than your average West Michigan pizza.  As a long time cook myself, this leads me to believe they are using whole milk mozzarella whereas some of the other establishments are using part skim mozzarella.  While I love the more greasy pizza, the downfall of Petrino's is that since it's a thinner crust frequently the pizza crust is flimsy and flops over when you pick up a slice.  It's not uncommon for me to have to use a fork and knife to eat the slices.  One way around this, is to ask for the pizza well down with a crisp crust.  Also I found that they use a lot of cheese on their pizza (especially if you order a plain pie)  Despite these criticisms, I reluctantly say that this is the most authentic New York pizza in the Holland-Zeeland area.

    Also, I feel compelled to mention this.  The strombolis here are amazing!  Vitales should take a lesson or two from this business on how to make strombolis.  Their strombolis are pretty simple, as they should be.  They have just ham, pepperoni, and mozzarella in them and are brushed with oil prior to cooking which gives them a nice golden and crispy outside.  I recommend getting the large.  It's about $13 though you will be amazed as to the size of the 'boli.  It's pretty close to 2 feet long!!!  It's easily 2 large meals.  Buon Appetito!